Double integral Nonsense VS Cord Tables
While looking through videos attempting to get
a better grip on the areas of circles while figuring out
the lunacy of the lunes
I came across this or it was sent to me by the Google librarian...
As soon as I saw the picture, i thought I would be able to do this
using the lune idea and basic arithmetic.
As it turns out, that was not the answer. The answer was much simpler
but it took me a few days to get a grip on how the whole thing works
after spending at least two days getting a grip on how in Geogebra,
depending on where you click, the point you see might not be where
you think it was meant to be and so the calculation you get is not
going to be agree with a number you see doing the arithmetic on
a spreadsheet or with a calculator.
I left the comment below on the video after figuring out how to do
this just using arithmetic in a five step process on any calculator
that has the ability to calculate circle percentages using the
infamous sine/cosine tables that were developed long after
the Greeks had learned from the Egyptians how to
do this arithmetic using what are now sometimes
called cords and other times called secants
and changed the name of the result
to radians in the ever ongoing
effort to pretend that these
things were not known
and used daily by
the egyptian
pyramid
builders
======================================================
From the linked Wikipedia article on
Ptolemy's table of chords
The table of chords, created by the Greek astronomer, geometer, and geographer Ptolemy in Egypt during the 2nd century AD, is a trigonometric table in Book I, chapter 11 of Ptolemy's Almagest,[1] a treatise on mathematical astronomy. It is essentially equivalent to a table of values of the sine function. It was the earliest trigonometric table extensive enough for many practical purposes, including those of astronomy.
Since the 8th and 9th centuries, the sine and other trigonometric functions have been used in Islamic mathematics and astronomy, reforming the production of sine tables.
Khwarizmi and Habash al-Hasib later produced a set of trigonometric tables.
==============================================
Fundamentally everything that can be calculated and known about
arc lengths and areas in circles is a function of right triangles
and ultimately reduces to the infamous 'pythagorean theorem'
where the one and only universal law of the universe that
Hydrogen knows as well as google or anyone made
of hydrogen who thinks they think better than
hydrogen thinks.
In mathematics, the Pythagorean theorem or Pythagoras's theorem
is the fundamental relation in Euclidean geometry
among the three sides of a right triangle.
and Every triangle can be decomposed
into two right triangles
the same way every tri
angle has three sides
and those three sides
determine the three
angles
==========================================================
A short list of triangle related terms
used regularly by the Egyptians from
your local librarian
Key details about triangle-shaped hieroglyphs and related symbols include:
• The "To Give" Sign (di): Often appearing as a small triangle, cone often badly
translated as a conical loaf of bread used in "offerings", or sometimes a representation of a bull's vertebra, it translates to "to give".
• The "Given Life" Combination (di ankh): When the triangular "giving" sign is paired directly with the Ankh (the symbol for life), the combination translates to "given life" or "given life for eternity". This pairing frequently appears in royal and funerary artwork (such as offerings presented to pharaohs or gods).
• Pyramid / Masons' Determinatives: A triangle placed on top of a rectangle was used as a determinative (a silent pictoral classifier) representing a pyramid (mr).
• The Benben: A standing triangular or conical stone mound known as the benben represented the primeval hill of creation from which the god Atum brought forth the world, serving as the architectural blueprint for the pyramids.
• Practical Triangles (The "Rope-Stretcher" Triangle): Beyond writing, the ancient Egyptians practically used a 3:4:5 right-angled triangle formed with a 12-knotted rope (the "Egyptian triangle") to survey land boundaries after the annual Nile floods and ensure accurate right angles.
more detail on how the triangle is a fundamental aspect of
life as seen through the eyes of the Pyramid builders
According to the research found in "The Quick and the Dead Biomedical research in ancient Egypt", the Ankh ( 𓋹 )—the universal symbol of life—is actually modeled after the thoracic vertebra of a bull when viewed in cross-section.
The primary symbols associated with a bull's spine include:
• The Ankh ( 𓋹 - Gardiner Sign List S34 ): Schwabe and Gordon argue that the loop represents the vertebral canal (where the spinal cord passes), the crossbar represents the transverse processes, and the stem represents the elongated spinous process characteristic of a bull's thoracic vertebrae. The ancient Egyptians believed that the spine was the biological source of semen and life-giving fluid, which explains why a vertebra would symbolize "life".
• The Djed Pillar ( 𓊽 - Gardiner Sign List R11): This symbol translates to "stability" and is widely accepted to represent a spine (traditionally the backbone of Osiris). In cattle culture theories, it specifically represents the sacrum or base of the bull's spine.
• The "To Give" Sign ( 𓏙 or 𓂤 - Gardiner Sign List X8 / D38): In standard Egyptology, the small triangle/cone most commonly represents a conical loaf of bread 'offered to the gods', which linguistically serves as the ideogram for di ("to give"). However, because the triangle (di) is so frequently fused directly to the front of the Ankh in artwork to mean "given life" (di ankh), anatomical theories treat the two as structurally and symbolically interconnected elements of the same vertebrae-based life force.
====================================================
It states that the area of the square
whose side is the hypotenuse
the side opposite the right angle
is equal to
the sum of the areas
of the squares
on the other
two sides
using this basic and fundamental law one can take this idea
and calculate the percentages of curve lengths and
the percentages of areas contained under
curved lengths as the ratios of the
right triangle never change
and so the percentages
never change.
The entirety of modern mathematics is an exercise
in giving these different parts and percentages
different names and pretending that something
other than what is observed in the universal
law represented by the 'pythagorean theorem'
exists. And it obviously does not once the
curtain is pulled back and the wizard is
exposed rattling his noisemakers.
===============================================
My comment on the youtube video
pretending to use integrals to
calculate the areas as some
process somehow different
from using the areas
and the known methods
of calculating the same.
it took me a few days to get myself up to speed on how to determine the angle at the center of a circle "subtending a cord".
I was pretty well convinced that there should be some method that would not rely on calculators or computers ...... the google librarian seems to want to convince anyone asking, that you use a calculator for this so I figured out how to do that and the rest of the work to get the answer to the question, once you have this angle which is nothing more than a percentage of the entire circle 'angle', is four operations on the same calculator involving nothing more than basic division and multiplication.given that you are using 'double integrals' I assume you are talking to people who understand the basics of the geometry of a circle and so know how to calculate the area of a circle the area of a rectangle and the area of triangles, so in steps 4 and 5 there are a two operations combined into one, one handed calculation, that I did on my pocket calculator (the phone that has all the answers)...
here is my best guess of how the Egyptian pyramid architects might have done this
1. Arccos(2/6) = 70.528
2. 70.528 X 2 = 141.057
3. 141.057 / 180 = .78365
4. .78365 x 36π/2 = 44.314
5. 44.314 - 8√2 = 33.0008
where
1. determines the angle defining half the cord/circular arc defined area
2. determines the angle defining the entire circular arc defined area
3. determines the percentage this angle represents relative to the 'angle' defining the semi circle
4. determines the area of the circular arc defined section relative to the full circular arc defined semi circle
5. subtracts the area of the rectangle formed by the two triangles below the defining cord at Y = 2
there is an old saw in 'mathematics' called Occam's razor. I think it applies here.
given the amount of time I spent asking the librarian questions about the angle
and the number of other videos I had to watch to get a firm grip on how this would
work using the most basic roots of the whole concept of geometry, it does not surprise
me that there is a 'crisis' where young people today do not seem to grok 'mathematics'
or arithmetic for that matter.
I'm nearing 70 years old now and spent my life not really understanding all of this in detail
until I started learning these things a few years ago. The explanations everywhere are all some multiple
of bad and some multiples of worse than bad. The Egyptians were doing this for a few thousand
years before they tried to teach the concepts to Pythagoras and a few hundred years later to Euclid.
something needs to change and that change means removing all the nonsense and going back to
basics as they were understood for a few thousand years before Euclid came into the picture.
amen my friend. I won't be wasting my time attempting to understand integrals or double integrals
any time soon but I do appreciate the empty space here to fill in the gaps where they seem to exist
for the average child who might come across this without the time I have available to do my homework.
===========================================================
In the example/problem above, the only thing one needs
to find is the percentage of the full/half circle
represented by the cone or the 'circular' area
originating from the center of the circle.
This is not a new idea or an idea that was only
looked into in the last couple of hundred years
or the last hundred years since electronic
devices began to be used to keep track
of things people were thinking about
and used to calculate things that one
must be able to calculate without
and electronic device in order to
get an electronic device to
calculate what one may
be thinking about.
Understand Sin/Cos
in the right triangle with
angles 36 54 and 90
the COSINE of 36 is .809
The SINE of 36 is .5877
The inverse COSINE of .809 / 1 is 36
the inverse COSINE of .5877 / 1 is 54
The cosine of 36 gives the length proportion of the
side connecting the angle in question to the right
angle controlling the form
This side is referred to as the adjacent side
The sine of 36 gives the length proportion of the side
opposite the angle in question to the right
angle controlling the form
This side is referred to as the opposite side.
The basic arithmetic involved is
.809^2 = .6544
and
.588^2 = .3457
and
.6544 + .3457 = 1.0034
the unser need only multiple each of these proportions
by the hypotenuse which is also the radius of the circle
in question to obtain the needed values for the triangle
formed in the circle with radius equal to something
other than unity the elusive one.
the sine/cosine table that was since the time of the
Ptolemy's printed for the casual calculator is then
nothing more than a set of values representing
percentages for the different right triangles
that can be found in the quarter circle
beginning with the triangle that
is also a straight line and
ending with the triangle
that forms the square
root of two as
the hypotenuse
The circle divides itself evenly into half
and the half circle divides itself into half.
this is what the entire cartesian coordinate
system is designed to represent and there is
nothing different happening in half a circle
or
in a quarter of a circle that is not happening
proportionately in a full circle.
Sadly, modern 'mathematics'
is doing nothing more than taking these same
things apart and then mis representing them
as something other than what they are by
re drawing the basics in ways that make it
appear as if something other than what is
happening is happening.
Then all the people who are called 'mathematicians'
spend all of their time attempting to get you to believe
that all the natural relationships that hydrogen knows
and uses to make itself into everything that is not called
hydrogen are something special that only special people
are capable of seeing and understanding.
The diagram above is the key to answering the
original question which restated can look like this
Find the area of the circular section defined by
a specific cord in a circle of a specific size.
The essence of the question revolves around
determining the percentage of the area of
the half circle and determining the specific parts
that compose the area to remove the bits that
need to be removed to find the answer.
The second most useful idea in 'mathematics'
after the law governing the side lengths of
triangles is the idea that the simplest
way to the solution is always the best.
Now as stated above, taking a circle apart in
even and equal pieces is does not change
any relationship involved in the circle
and so the majority of 'mathematics'
becomes the 'problem' of understanding
the parts and how those parts relate to
the whole in percentage terms.
Many different techniques for this process have
been developed over the last say 2500 years or so
fundamentally because the Egyptian language which
was used by the Egyptians for at least 2500 years
before the last 2500 years started to be counted
has become lost to nonsense
and the methods used by the Egyptians to take the
circle apart and put it back together are all lost
to babble that began right around the time of
the ptolemy's, an incestuous family of 'kings'
who did what everyone before them had been
doing in a language that survives to this day.
That language is Greek and in all of 'scientific'
practice today, Greek 'letters' are used to
represent ideas and unknowns.
Θ is one of those symbols and as it turns out
you don't need to have a PHD in rocket science
to understand what Θ looks like relative
to a circle or a circle divided in half.
Dividing the circle into 360 equal segments is an idea
that some shiny penny came up with long ago when
base 60, the system we still use today to tell time
with was used and understood broadly. Most likely
the same way the system is used broadly today with
the caveat that then people understood what they
were doing and now, if you ask ten people if they
know of a system that used base 60 nine of them
will say no and the other one might say yes and
give some example that is not the one that everyone
around the globe understands perfectly which is
time and the system of time keeping where 60
is defined as one.
This leads us right into the question of
what is a radian
and the answer
is the same
answer
that one gets when
one thinks about an hour
for a minute or a second
the unit name and the
created units are
just not familiar
but the concept
is the same
so to tell time correctly
one takes a circle and
divides the circle into 60
units.
This is another way to say
that 60 becomes 1
and so 1 of 60 minutes
is represented as 1/60
the circle as we have already seen
is divided into 360 degrees making
360 equal to 1 and so 1 degree
is represented by 1/360
The circle is
as we have seen always
divided by the unit π
and by the 2 X the radius
as the multiplier
where the circle
of radius 1 has
circumference 2π
and the circle of
radius 1/2 has
circumference π
the idea of radians
combines these two
divisions into one idea
and defines unity
or the circumference
of any circle
as 2π X R
all that is being done here
is to give another name to
the circumference so that
this curved line can be
thought of and used as
a straight line.
and since the days that
electronic devices were
created to do arithmetic
for people, this imaginary
name has been used to
eliminate the need for
the user to remember the
value of 2π
6.2831853071795....
where the ... goes on
and on forever
and the fact that for
operations requiring
a high degree of accuracy
6.28 is not approximate enough
and 6.28 is not a nice round number
like 60 or 360 which anyone can remember
with very little difficulty.
and so one degree out of 360
is said to represent a straight line
of length 0.0174532925199432.....
which is nothing more than
6.28.... divided by 360
or π / 180
another number that
is not easy to remember
for people but very easy
to remember for any
electronic device that
people use to do arithmetic.
So when you use your pocket calculator
to figure out the percentage of a circle
represented by a certain angle you do not
need to do the arithmetic to convert the
sides of the triangle you are evaluating
to the equivalent curved arc as a percentage
of one complete circle...
and you just give the side lengths
of the triangle you are eveluating to
your electronic arithmetic machine and
it takes care of remembering how to
convert those straight line values
into the value of the arc of the unit circle
The arc length of a semi circle with
radius one is equal to π
and because π
is not a number
like 60 which is
evenly divisible by
2 and or 3
the multiples
of π
and the divisors
of π
are not familiar
to people who do
not do geometry
and arithmetic the
way the egyptians
did for 2500 or 25000
years before some french
guy with no geometry training
decided he knew what the egyptians
were talking about 2500 years after
everyone and their brother forgot what
the egyptians were talking about.
multiples of
π
π
and that every portion of a circle is a percentage
of the whole represented by the idea that
360 is unity in the same way that
60 is unity in base 60
finding the parts
of a piece of a
circle is
circular
logic
Alternative solution to the stated problem using the
not taught in school idea that Archimedes wrote about
a long long time ago after he learned how to think
like an Egyptian from the Egyptians
.png)




.png)

.png)

.png)
Comments
Post a Comment